Tuesday, February 24, 2009

A Surprising Editorial in the (gasp) NY Times

A Surprising Editorial in the (gasp) NY Times

The Big Test

By DAVID BROOKS Feb. 21, 2009 New York Times

“We cannot successfully address any of our problems without addressing all of them.”
Barack Obama

When I was a freshman in college, I was assigned “Reflections on the Revolution in France” by Edmund Burke. I loathed the book. Burke argued that each individual’s private stock of reason is small and that political decisions should be guided by the accumulated wisdom of the ages. Change is necessary, Burke continued, but it should be gradual, not disruptive. For a young democratic socialist, hoping to help begin the world anew, this seemed like a reactionary retreat into passivity.

Over the years, I have come to see that Burke had a point. The political history of the 20th century is the history of social-engineering projects executed by well-intentioned people that began well and ended badly. There were big errors like communism, but also lesser ones, like a Vietnam War designed by the best and the brightest, urban renewal efforts that decimated neighborhoods, welfare policies that had the unintended effect of weakening families and development programs that left a string of white elephant projects across the world.

These experiences drove me toward the crooked timber school of public philosophy: Michael Oakeshott, Isaiah Berlin, Edward Banfield, Reinhold Niebuhr, Friedrich Hayek, Clinton Rossiter and George Orwell. These writers — some left, some right — had a sense of epistemological modesty. They knew how little we can know. They understood that we are strangers to ourselves and society is an immeasurably complex organism. They tended to be skeptical of technocratic, rationalist planning and suspicious of schemes to reorganize society from the top down.

Before long, I was no longer a liberal. Liberals are more optimistic about the capacity of individual reason and the government’s ability to execute transformational change. They have more faith in the power of social science, macroeconomic models and 10-point programs.

Readers of this column know that I am a great admirer of Barack Obama and those around him. And yet the gap between my epistemological modesty and their liberal worldviews has been evident over the past few weeks. The people in the administration are surrounded by a galaxy of unknowns, and yet they see this economic crisis as an opportunity to expand their reach, to take bigger risks and, as Obama said on Saturday, to tackle every major problem at once.

President Obama has concentrated enormous power on a few aides in the West Wing of the White House. These aides are unrolling a rapid string of plans: to create three million jobs, to redesign the health care system, to save the auto industry, to revive the housing industry, to reinvent the energy sector, to revitalize the banks, to reform the schools — and to do it all while cutting the deficit in half.

If ever this kind of domestic revolution were possible, this is the time and these are the people to do it. The crisis demands a large response. The people around Obama are smart and sober. Their plans are bold but seem supple and chastened by a realistic sensibility.

Yet they set off my Burkean alarm bells. I fear that in trying to do everything at once, they will do nothing well. I fear that we have a group of people who haven’t even learned to use their new phone system trying to redesign half the U.S. economy.

I fear they are going to try to undertake the biggest administrative challenge in American history while refusing to hire the people who can help the most: agency veterans who are registered lobbyists.

I worry that we’re operating far beyond our economic knowledge. Every time the administration releases an initiative, I read 20 different economists with 20 different opinions. I worry that we lack the political structures to regain fiscal control. Deficits are exploding, and the president clearly wants to restrain them.

But there’s no evidence that Democrats and Republicans in Congress have the courage or the mutual trust required to share the blame when taxes have to rise and benefits have to be cut.

All in all, I can see why the markets are nervous and dropping. And it’s also clear that we’re on the cusp of the biggest political experiment of our lifetimes. If Obama is mostly successful, then the epistemological skepticism natural to conservatives will have been discredited. We will know that highly trained government experts are capable of quickly designing and executing top-down transformational change. If they mostly fail, then liberalism will suffer a grievous blow, and conservatives will be called upon to restore order and sanity.

It’ll be interesting to see who’s right. But I can’t even root for my own vindication. The costs are too high. I have to go to the keyboard each morning hoping Barack Obama is going to prove me wrong.
What is really roiling the market is the ineptness being shown by Obama. The deepening recession ahead of us had already been priced into the stock market last summer. He talks the talk, but can't walk the walk.


AddThis Social Bookmark Button


At 5:33 PM, Anonymous Joe said...

Obama is probably speaking at this very moment. I usually turn on the O'Reilly Factor at 8:00 PM, but knowing that Obama is going to be talking the economy down again, and blaming the Bush Administration for this mess, I find it very hard to sit down and listen to a liar who stretches the truth, and goes back on every promise that he makes. To me, this man is not a very credible leader. He's arrogant and inept for this job. Hillary Clinton best described him as an "OJT" candidate and country singer, Trace Atkins describes Obama as resembling a "Deer in the headlights of a car." Obama is probably going to tell everyone tonight that he will have the deficit cut in half before he leaves office. My question is; Why even have a pork filled deficit that large in the first place? How about we, getting someone in there who can use Reaganomics to cure this financial mess? It worked before and it can work again. I see a big revolution in the making and I wouldn't be a bit surprised if people are thrown in prison for speaking out against him like in the 1900's when people were thrown into prison for speaking out against World War 1. History always repeats itself.

At 7:18 AM, Blogger René O'Deay said...

Just his statement alone: 'refusing to hire the people who can help the most: agency veterans who are registered lobbyists.' makes me realize just how blind supporters of BHO actually are.

At 9:22 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I like Brooks. Always have. He usually has a voice of reason somewhere in the middle...just to the right.


At 6:42 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...


[url=]buy best prices marlboro cigarettes [/url]
buying discount cigarettes marlboro cigarettes buy now pay later buy marlboro menthol cigarettes online
[url=]buy cigarettes from an indian reservation [/url]
buy cigarettes from japan cigarette boat buy buy cigarettes online from discount store
[url=]buy newport cigarettes online [/url]
buy winston cigarettes buy cigarettes in amsterdam buying cigarettes overseas
[url=]buy fiesta cigarettes [/url]
discount mail order cigarettes buy barclay cigarettes still available order discount cigarettes online
[url=]cigarette holders where to buy [/url]
buying cigaretts buy cheap cartons of cigarettes cheap cigarettes to buy
[url=]buying cigarette [/url]
order non fire safe cigarettes best site to buy cigarettes buying cigarettes online canada
[url=]where to buy cigarettes in north carolina [/url]
order cigarettes from egypt buy cigarettes by the pack candy cigarettes where to buy
[url=]buy the cheapest cigarettes in [/url]
age to buy cigarettes quebec buy marlboro cigarettes online buy cigarette holders in
[url=]buy exoctic flavored cigarettes [/url]
buy seneca cigarettes online buy marlboro light cigarettes online mail order cigarettes indian
[url=]expense of buying cigarettes [/url]
buy exoctic flavored cigarettes buying cigarettes in new york state order japanese cigarettes

At 10:04 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...


[url=]What is/are Zovirax Tablets?[/url]
What are acyclovir tablets or capsules?
ACYCLOVIR (Zovirax®) treats standard types of viral infections, specifically herpes infections. Acyclovir
will not cure herpes infections; it choice relieve the sores mend faster and workers to release the pain or discomfort.
Every once in a while acyclovir is given to help avert the infection from coming back. Acyclovir also treats shingles
and chickenpox infections. Generic acyclovir tablets and capsules are available.

What should I acquaint someone with something my fitness distress provider in the vanguard I be involved this medicine?
They destitution to know if you have any of these conditions:

•neurological condition
•kidney illness
•seizures (convulsions)
•an bizarre or allergic resistance to acyclovir, ganciclovir, valacyclovir, valganciclovir, other medicines, foods, dyes, or preservatives
•in the pudding club or trying to receive in the pudding club


[url= ]Zovirax online consultantZovirax with no prescriptions [/url]
canadian Zovirax diet pills without prescriptionbuy Zovirax free consultation
[url= ]no prescription Zovirax with fedexZovirax no script fedex [/url]
only Zovirax free consultZovirax without a script
[url= ]Zovirax free fedex shippingorder Zovirax with no prescription [/url]
overnight delivery of Zovirax with no prescriptionorder Zovirax overnight cod
[url= ]Zovirax for salegeneric Zovirax online [/url]
Zovirax no prescriptions needed codZovirax saturday delivery
[url= ]Zovirax with saturday deliveryZovirax without prescription cheap [/url]
Zovirax overniZovirax online without presciption
[url= ]buy cheap Zovirax online Zovirax prescriptions [/url]
order prescription Zoviraxcheap overnight Zovirax
[url= ]online Zoviraxcheap fedex Zovirax [/url]
buy Zovirax prescriptionspurchase Zovirax without a prescription
[url= ]Zovirax Zoviraxbuy Zovirax hcl [/url]
buy Zovirax online pharmacybuy cheap discount Zovirax
[url= ]cheap online ZoviraxZovirax online saturday delivery [/url]
Zovirax overnight delivery onlybuy Zovirax without a prescription
[url= ]buy Zovirax no prescription needed120 Zovirax free [/url]
purchase Zovirax cod shippingbuy cheap Zovirax prescriptions online


Post a Comment

<< Home